When the Old Self Finally Loses Its Grip

I want to begin this reflection on Colossians 3 by naming something most people feel but rarely articulate clearly: the exhaustion that comes from trying to change without knowing who you are changing into. Many believers know what they are supposed to stop doing. Fewer know how to live with a settled sense of identity that makes old habits feel irrelevant instead of forbidden. Colossians 3 is not a chapter about behavior modification. It is a chapter about gravity—about what naturally rises when something heavier finally releases its hold.

Paul is not speaking to people who doubt God’s existence. He is speaking to people who believe, who attend, who serve, who know the language of faith, and yet still feel pulled backward by patterns they thought conversion would erase. This chapter does not shame that experience. It explains it. And then it does something more radical than issuing commands: it relocates the believer’s center of life entirely.

The opening line of Colossians 3 does not say, “If you want to be better.” It says, “If then you have been raised with Christ.” That conditional phrase is not motivational; it is declarative. Paul assumes resurrection as a settled fact for the believer. The question is not whether you have new life, but where you are trying to live from. Most spiritual frustration comes from resurrected people attempting to operate from a buried identity. Colossians 3 exposes that misalignment gently but unmistakably.

When Paul says to seek the things that are above, he is not instructing believers to disengage from earthly responsibility or human emotion. He is reordering attention. What you consistently attend to becomes what you eventually obey. Desire follows focus long before it produces behavior. This is why Paul addresses the mind before the body, and identity before instruction. He knows that whatever commands follow will fail unless the center of gravity has already shifted.

One of the most misunderstood lines in this chapter is the statement that your life is hidden with Christ in God. Many read that as poetic comfort. It is more than that. It is a statement of security and invisibility at the same time. Hidden does not mean absent. It means protected from false definitions. It means your truest self is no longer available for public trial, personal condemnation, or internal prosecution. You may still feel accused, but the court that matters no longer recognizes the charges.

This hiddenness is not escapism. It is stabilization. A life exposed to every opinion, every failure, every memory, and every expectation cannot remain steady. Paul is anchoring the believer somewhere inaccessible to shame. He is saying, in effect, that the most important thing about you is no longer available to be rewritten by your worst moment.

Only after establishing this does Paul speak about putting to death what belongs to the earthly nature. Notice the order. He does not say, “Kill these sins so that you can be raised.” He says, “Because you are raised, these things no longer fit.” The language of death here is not violent; it is diagnostic. You do not have to kill what is already losing oxygen. When identity changes, certain behaviors suffocate naturally.

Paul lists sexual immorality, impurity, passion, evil desire, and greed, which he names as idolatry. This is not a random list of moral failures. It is a pattern of misdirected longing. Every item on that list involves desire detached from identity. When people do not know who they are, they try to feel alive through appetite. Paul is not condemning desire; he is diagnosing its misplacement.

Greed is called idolatry not because money is evil, but because greed asks a created thing to do the work of a creator. It asks possessions to secure identity, safety, and worth. That same exchange happens with sex, power, approval, and control. Colossians 3 exposes idolatry not as rebellion first, but as confusion. You worship what you believe will hold you together.

Paul then speaks of wrath, anger, malice, slander, and filthy language. These are not simply “attitude problems.” They are the reflexes of a threatened self. When identity feels fragile, anger becomes a defense mechanism. When worth feels uncertain, speech becomes a weapon. Colossians 3 is not saying, “Try harder to be nice.” It is saying, “Stop living as though your life is still up for negotiation.”

One of the most freeing lines in this chapter is the command to stop lying to one another, because you have put off the old self with its practices. Lying is not only about false statements. It is about presenting a version of yourself you think will survive better than the truth. Paul assumes that honesty becomes possible when survival no longer depends on performance. The old self lies because it must. The new self tells the truth because it can.

Paul’s language of putting off and putting on is deeply intentional. He does not describe surgery or reconstruction. He describes clothing. This matters. Clothing is not your body, but it does shape how you move through the world. The old self is not annihilated; it is undressed. It no longer defines you, but it may still be familiar. Many believers struggle not because they want their old life back, but because they have not yet learned how to walk without it.

The new self, Paul says, is being renewed in knowledge after the image of its creator. Renewal here is ongoing, not instantaneous. This dismantles the myth that spiritual maturity is the absence of struggle. Renewal assumes process. It assumes learning. It assumes repetition. The image being restored is not an abstract ideal. It is relational. You are becoming more like the one you are connected to, not the one you are trying to impress.

Paul then collapses the categories that typically divide humanity: Greek and Jew, circumcised and uncircumcised, barbarian, Scythian, slave, free. These were not theoretical divisions. They were social realities that structured power, access, and belonging. Paul is not saying these differences disappear. He is saying they no longer function as identity anchors. Christ is all, and in all. That is not a slogan. It is a redefinition of worth.

This matters deeply in a world obsessed with labels. Colossians 3 does not erase uniqueness; it disarms hierarchy. It does not flatten personality; it removes superiority. When Christ becomes the defining reality, difference no longer threatens unity. And unity no longer requires sameness. This is not forced harmony. It is shared grounding.

Only after all of this does Paul move into what many readers mistakenly treat as the core of the chapter: compassion, kindness, humility, meekness, and patience. These are not virtues you grit your teeth into. They are the natural behaviors of a secure self. Compassion flows when you no longer need to compete. Kindness grows when you are not guarding your position. Humility emerges when your value is no longer self-generated.

Paul urges believers to bear with one another and forgive as the Lord forgave them. Forgiveness here is not emotional amnesia. It is the refusal to extract payment from people who cannot repay you anyway. Forgiveness is possible when your sense of justice is anchored in something larger than personal vindication. Colossians 3 does not minimize harm. It reframes authority.

Above all, Paul says, put on love, which binds everything together in perfect harmony. Love is not presented as one virtue among many. It is the connective tissue. Without love, virtues become performative. With love, even imperfect actions carry healing weight. Love is what keeps compassion from becoming condescension and humility from becoming self-erasure.

Then comes one of the most overlooked instructions in the chapter: let the peace of Christ rule in your hearts. The word “rule” here implies arbitration. Peace is not just a feeling; it is a decision-making authority. Paul is saying that peace should be allowed to settle disputes within you. Many believers ask whether something is permissible, effective, or impressive. Paul suggests a better question: does it fracture or preserve the peace that Christ has already established?

This peace is communal as well as internal. You were called into one body, Paul says. Gratitude follows naturally. Thankfulness is not a personality trait; it is a byproduct of belonging. People who know they are part of something larger stop obsessing over what they lack. Gratitude grows where isolation dissolves.

Paul then instructs believers to let the word of Christ dwell richly among them, teaching and admonishing one another with wisdom, singing psalms, hymns, and spiritual songs with thankfulness. This is not about musical preference. It is about saturation. The word does not visit occasionally; it takes up residence. When truth becomes familiar, correction feels less like attack and more like alignment.

What Paul describes here is not a church service structure. It is a shared life rhythm. Teaching and admonition happen in relationship. Worship emerges from gratitude, not obligation. When truth is internalized, it spills out in ways that reinforce rather than regulate community.

Finally, Paul delivers a sentence that quietly governs everything that precedes it: whatever you do, in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him. This is not a religious tagline. It is a totalizing orientation. Doing something in someone’s name means acting as their representative. It means your actions echo their character.

Colossians 3 does not ask believers to add Jesus to their lives. It asks them to let him redefine what life is. When that happens, obedience stops feeling like compliance and starts feeling like coherence. Your life begins to make sense again.

This chapter is not a checklist. It is a relocation. It moves the believer from self-management to shared life, from fear-driven behavior to peace-led action, from identity as performance to identity as participation. It does not promise ease. It promises alignment. And alignment, while sometimes uncomfortable, is always freeing.

Now, I want to take this theology of identity and walk it directly into the most ordinary, and often most difficult, spaces of daily life—relationships, work, authority, and endurance. Because Colossians 3 does not end with spiritual ideals. It ends with lived reality. And that is where its power becomes unmistakable.

Colossians 3 does not retreat from everyday life once it finishes speaking about inner renewal. It moves straight into the spaces where identity is most tested: relationships, responsibility, authority, fatigue, and obedience when no one is watching. This is where many believers quietly disconnect theology from reality. They resonate deeply with the opening vision of being raised with Christ, but then assume the rest of life must still be managed through grit, endurance, or survival. Paul refuses that separation. He insists that resurrection identity must govern the most practical corners of human existence, or it has not truly taken root.

When Paul transitions into instructions about relationships, he does so without resetting the foundation. He does not say, “Now forget everything I just said and try harder here.” He assumes the new self is already active. The commands that follow are not corrective add-ons. They are applications of identity. This matters deeply, because many people read the latter part of Colossians 3 as a list of heavy obligations rather than a description of what a re-centered life looks like when lived honestly.

Paul addresses wives and husbands, children and parents, servants and masters. These categories reflect the social structures of the time, but the underlying logic reaches beyond historical roles. Paul is not reinforcing hierarchy for its own sake. He is redefining power through Christ-shaped identity. Every instruction in this section quietly undermines domination and replaces it with responsibility.

Submission, for example, is often misunderstood because it is severed from context. Paul does not command submission in a vacuum. He roots it “in the Lord.” That phrase changes everything. Submission here is not self-erasure or enforced silence. It is alignment with a higher authority that already affirms worth. Only someone secure in identity can submit without disappearing. Insecure people either resist all authority or surrender to it destructively. Colossians 3 offers a third way: voluntary alignment grounded in confidence, not fear.

When Paul speaks to husbands, he does not grant license to control. He demands love, and not the sentimental version. He warns explicitly against harshness. This is radical when understood properly. Harshness is the misuse of strength. Paul assumes husbands have power and tells them they will be judged not for possessing it, but for how they restrain it. Love here is not emotion; it is stewardship.

Children are instructed to obey, but parents are warned not to provoke or embitter them. That warning reveals something crucial: authority that crushes spirit is disobedient to Christ even if it appears orderly. Paul is not interested in compliant households that produce discouraged souls. He is concerned with environments that reflect the patience and gentleness of God. The goal is not control. The goal is formation.

Then Paul turns to servants and masters, language that immediately raises modern concerns. But again, the transformative force is not found in the labels but in the reframing of accountability. Paul speaks directly to those with the least visible power and tells them that their work, even when unseen or uncelebrated, is noticed by the Lord. This is not a call to accept injustice as virtuous. It is a declaration that worth is not canceled by circumstance.

Paul dismantles the idea that value flows from position. He relocates dignity to faithfulness. Work done sincerely, he says, is done for the Lord, not merely for human overseers. This reframing does not glorify exploitation. It preserves identity where systems fail to protect it. Many believers today feel trapped in roles they did not choose, laboring without recognition. Colossians 3 does not deny that pain. It anchors meaning somewhere that systems cannot reach.

Masters are reminded that they, too, have a Master in heaven. That single sentence levels the entire field. Authority does not disappear, but accountability becomes unavoidable. Power is no longer ultimate. It is borrowed. And borrowed authority carries responsibility, not entitlement. In Christ, no one outranks judgment, and no one falls beneath care.

What ties this entire chapter together is not moral aspiration but consistency of identity. Paul is relentless about one thing: who you are in Christ must govern how you live everywhere else. There is no sacred-secular divide here. There is no permission to behave one way privately and another publicly. The new self is not situational. It is comprehensive.

One of the quiet challenges of Colossians 3 is that it refuses to let believers compartmentalize transformation. You cannot claim spiritual depth while nurturing relational harm. You cannot pursue holiness while excusing cruelty. You cannot speak the language of grace while practicing manipulation. Paul’s vision is integrated. Everything touches everything else.

This is why gratitude keeps resurfacing throughout the chapter. Gratitude is the emotional signature of alignment. When identity settles, comparison fades. When comparison fades, resentment loosens. When resentment loosens, thankfulness has room to grow. Gratitude is not demanded here as politeness. It emerges as a symptom of health.

Another overlooked theme in Colossians 3 is endurance without bitterness. Paul does not promise ease. He promises coherence. Many believers confuse suffering with failure, especially when obedience does not immediately produce visible reward. Colossians 3 reorients expectations. Faithfulness may be costly, but it is never wasted. No act done in Christ is invisible, even when it is unrewarded on earth.

This chapter also challenges performative spirituality. Paul repeatedly warns against eye-service, doing things only to be seen. That warning extends beyond labor. It applies to kindness that exists for recognition, humility that seeks admiration, and obedience that collapses when applause disappears. The new self does not require witnesses to remain intact. It lives before God, not an audience.

Colossians 3 also quietly addresses shame, though the word never appears. Shame thrives where identity is fragile. It feeds on secrecy and isolation. Paul’s insistence that believers are hidden with Christ dismantles shame at its root. When your life is secured in someone else’s faithfulness, your failures lose their power to define you.

This is why Paul does not motivate through fear. He does not threaten loss of salvation. He does not shame believers into compliance. He assumes transformation is already underway and calls them to live in alignment with what is true. This approach respects agency. It trusts the Spirit. And it honors the believer as a participant, not a project.

Colossians 3 is especially relevant in a time when identity is both aggressively constructed and easily shattered. Many people today are exhausted from self-curation, constantly managing how they are perceived while secretly unsure who they are. This chapter offers relief. It says you do not need to invent yourself. You need to remember where your life is anchored.

The old self loses its grip not through force, but through irrelevance. When something better takes its place, the old patterns no longer satisfy. This is why Paul does not obsess over sin. He obsesses over vision. He knows that people change most deeply not when they fear consequences, but when they encounter a truer version of themselves.

Colossians 3 ultimately invites believers into maturity that is quiet, grounded, and resilient. It does not promise intensity or constant emotional highs. It promises steadiness. It offers a life where peace can rule, love can bind, and gratitude can sustain even under pressure.

To live Colossians 3 is to wake up each day not asking, “How do I avoid failure?” but, “How do I live from what is already true?” It is to treat obedience not as debt repayment, but as alignment. It is to stop negotiating worth and start expressing it.

The chapter closes not with a dramatic flourish, but with a comprehensive orientation: whatever you do, do it in the name of the Lord Jesus. That is not a burden. It is a simplification. You no longer have to wonder who you are becoming. You already know whose you are.

And when that truth finally settles, the old self does not need to be fought every day. It simply stops feeling like home.

Watch Douglas Vandergraph’s inspiring faith-based videos on YouTube.

Support the ministry by buying Douglas a coffee.

Your friend,
Douglas Vandergraph

#Colossians3 #ChristianIdentity #FaithInPractice #SpiritualGrowth #BiblicalLiving #NewLifeInChrist #ChristianEncouragement #FaithJourney