The Day Faith Grew Up: Galatians 4 and the Moment Religion Became Relationship

There is a moment in every human life when childhood ends, not because a birthday passes, but because something inside finally wakes up. A moment when you realize you are no longer living under someone else’s rules simply because they are rules. You begin to understand why you do what you do. You move from obedience by force to obedience by choice. You stop being managed and start being entrusted. Galatians 4 lives in that moment. It is one of the most emotionally charged, theologically daring, and spiritually intimate chapters Paul ever wrote, and yet many believers read it as if it were a legal memo instead of a love letter. Galatians 4 is not about religious systems at all. It is about growing up.

Paul is not arguing doctrine for sport here. He is pleading for maturity. He is looking at people who have been given freedom and are voluntarily crawling back into chains, and he cannot understand why. His words are not cold or academic. They are wounded, parental, almost desperate. Galatians 4 is what happens when a spiritual father watches his children trade inheritance for supervision, sonship for servitude, and intimacy for control.

The tragedy Paul sees is not rebellion. It is regression.

He opens the chapter with a metaphor so ordinary that it would have landed immediately in the ancient world, and yet so profound that it still unsettles modern faith. An heir, Paul says, while still a child, is no different from a slave. Even though everything belongs to him, he lives under guardians and managers until the time set by his father. In other words, ownership without maturity feels exactly like bondage. Promise without readiness looks like restriction. Inheritance delayed feels indistinguishable from imprisonment.

Paul is telling us something uncomfortable here. God uses structure for a season, not as a destination. Law is not the enemy, but it is not the home. Rules are not evil, but they are not relational. They exist to guide immature hearts until love is strong enough to lead on its own.

This is where many believers quietly stall.

We come to Christ, and structure saves us. Boundaries protect us. Disciplines steady us. Rules give us clarity when our desires are chaotic. And for a season, that is not only good, it is necessary. But Galatians 4 confronts the moment when what once protected you begins to restrain you, when the scaffolding that helped build the house is never taken down, and you start mistaking construction for living.

Paul says plainly that before Christ, we were enslaved under the “elemental spiritual forces of the world.” That phrase has been debated for centuries, but its emotional weight is unmistakable. It refers to systems that manage behavior without transforming hearts. Structures that control outcomes but never heal identity. Patterns that tell you what to do but never tell you who you are.

Then Paul drops one of the most breathtaking sentences in all of Scripture, and he does it almost casually, as if he assumes we might miss how earth-shattering it is.

“But when the fullness of time had come, God sent his Son.”

Not when humanity improved. Not when religion matured. Not when law finally worked. When time itself was ripe, God did not send a new rulebook. He sent a person. Born of a woman. Born under the law. Subject to the very system He came to fulfill and outgrow.

And why?

“To redeem those under the law, that we might receive adoption to sonship.”

This is the axis on which Galatians 4 turns. Redemption is not the end goal. Adoption is. Forgiveness is not the finish line. Belonging is. The gospel is not about making bad people behave better. It is about making enslaved people sons and daughters.

Paul is saying something radical here that many churches still struggle to live out. God did not save you to manage you forever. He saved you to trust you. He did not rescue you to keep you on probation. He rescued you to bring you home.

And because you are sons, Paul says, God sent the Spirit of His Son into our hearts, crying, “Abba, Father.”

Not “Master.”
Not “Supervisor.”
Not “Judge.”

Abba.

This is not formal language. This is not ceremonial prayer. This is the sound a child makes when they stop explaining themselves and simply reach for their parent. It is intimate. It is unguarded. It is the cry that assumes safety without needing proof.

Paul is dismantling an entire religious worldview in a single paragraph. If the Spirit inside you cries “Abba,” then your relationship with God is not primarily contractual. It is familial. You are not earning proximity. You are expressing belonging.

“So you are no longer a slave, but God’s child,” Paul concludes, “and since you are his child, God has made you also an heir.”

That word heir matters more than we often realize. An heir does not beg for permission. An heir does not negotiate worth. An heir does not fear abandonment every time they fail. An heir may be disciplined, corrected, and guided, but never disowned. The discipline of a father is not the punishment of a judge. One aims to restore, the other to condemn.

This is where Galatians 4 becomes deeply personal and deeply confronting.

Because Paul is not speaking to atheists. He is speaking to believers who know God, and yet are choosing to live as if they do not trust Him.

He reminds them of their past, not to shame them, but to awaken them. Before they knew God, they were enslaved to things that were not gods at all. Now that they know God—or rather, are known by God—why are they turning back to weak and miserable forces? Why are they submitting again to rules that cannot give life?

This is not a critique of obedience. It is a critique of fear-based faith.

Paul is watching people replace relationship with ritual. He sees them trading sonship for systems because systems feel safer. Rules feel predictable. Performance gives the illusion of control. Relationship, by contrast, requires trust. It requires vulnerability. It requires the terrifying freedom of being loved without leverage.

Then Paul says something that feels almost modern in its psychological insight. He points out their obsession with observing special days, months, seasons, and years. Religious calendars. Sacred schedules. Ritual markers that feel holy but quietly become substitutes for intimacy.

And then he says the words no leader wants to say out loud.

“I fear for you, that somehow I have wasted my efforts on you.”

This is not theological frustration. This is heartbreak. Paul is not angry. He is afraid. Afraid that they have learned the language of faith without absorbing its heart. Afraid that they have memorized behaviors without internalizing identity. Afraid that they have mistaken maturity for rule-keeping instead of trust.

At this point, the letter turns deeply personal.

Paul reminds them of how they first received him. He had come to them weak, possibly sick, unimpressive by worldly standards. He did not arrive with dominance or polish. And yet they welcomed him as if he were an angel of God, as if he were Christ Himself. They would have done anything for him then. Their joy was raw. Their faith was alive.

And now?

“What has happened to all your joy?”

That question echoes far beyond Galatia. It echoes in churches full of exhausted believers. It echoes in people who know all the rules but feel none of the delight. It echoes in faith that is correct but not alive.

Paul is not asking why they stopped obeying. He is asking why they stopped rejoicing.

He tells them the truth hurts now because it threatens the systems they are clinging to. He has become their enemy by telling them the truth, not because the truth changed, but because their hearts did. Others are courting them zealously, Paul says, but not for good. They want to isolate them, to make them dependent, to make themselves necessary.

That line alone could be written about much of modern religious culture.

Paul contrasts that with his own posture. He is not trying to control them. He is in pain for them. “My dear children,” he writes, “for whom I am again in the pains of childbirth until Christ is formed in you.”

Not until behavior improves.
Not until attendance stabilizes.
Not until compliance is achieved.

Until Christ is formed in you.

That is the true goal of spiritual life. Not conformity, but formation. Not rule mastery, but inner transformation. Not managed morality, but matured love.

Paul wishes he could be with them, to change his tone, to speak face to face, because he is perplexed. He does not know how to reach people who are choosing chains while holding keys.

And then, just as you think he has said everything he can say, Paul introduces an allegory that turns the entire argument on its head. He reaches back into Israel’s story and pulls forward Hagar and Sarah, Ishmael and Isaac, slavery and promise. But this is not a history lesson. It is a mirror.

And that is where Galatians 4 becomes impossible to read comfortably.

Because Paul is about to ask a question that still exposes us today.

Are you living as a child of promise… or as a child of control?

Paul does not introduce the story of Hagar and Sarah to sound clever or scholarly. He introduces it because the Galatians are repeating it in real time. They are not reading an ancient mistake. They are reenacting it. And Paul wants them to see themselves clearly enough to stop.

He asks a piercing question before he even begins the allegory. “Tell me, you who want to be under the law, are you not aware of what the law says?” In other words, if you insist on living by rules, have you actually listened to what those rules were trying to teach you in the first place? Because the law itself never claimed to be the destination. It was always pointing beyond itself.

Abraham had two sons. One was born according to the flesh. The other was born as the result of a promise. Ishmael came from human strategy. Isaac came from divine timing. One was produced by anxiety. The other by trust. One was an attempt to force God’s hand. The other was the result of waiting long enough for God to move on His own.

Paul is not insulting Abraham here. He is diagnosing a pattern we all repeat. When waiting becomes uncomfortable, we reach for control. When trust feels risky, we build systems. When promise seems delayed, we manufacture outcomes. And when we do, we may still get results, but they are not the inheritance God intended.

Hagar represents religion powered by human effort. Sarah represents relationship sustained by divine promise. Ishmael represents what we can accomplish when fear takes over. Isaac represents what only God can produce when faith holds steady.

Paul says these two women represent two covenants. One produces slavery. The other produces freedom. And then he does something shocking. He aligns Mount Sinai, the place of the law, with slavery, and he aligns the promise with freedom. This would have unsettled any first-century religious mind. Sinai was sacred. Law was holy. Yet Paul dares to say that holiness without intimacy still enslaves.

The problem is not the law. The problem is trying to live as if the law is the source of life.

Paul pushes even further. He says that just as the child born according to the flesh persecuted the child born by the power of the Spirit, so it is now. Legalism always persecutes freedom. Systems always resent grace. Control always feels threatened by trust. Performance-based religion cannot tolerate a faith that rests instead of strives.

That truth has not aged out.

Whenever someone begins to live from identity instead of fear, they are questioned. Whenever someone refuses to be managed by guilt, they are accused of being careless. Whenever someone prioritizes relationship over ritual, they are warned they are becoming dangerous. Freedom is always misunderstood by those who have learned to survive through control.

Paul quotes Scripture bluntly. “Get rid of the slave woman and her son, for the slave woman’s son will never share in the inheritance with the free woman’s son.” This is not cruelty. It is clarity. Slavery and sonship cannot coexist. You cannot inherit as a child while living as a servant. You cannot be formed by grace while submitting to fear as your master.

Then Paul delivers his conclusion with unmistakable force.

“Therefore, brothers and sisters, we are not children of the slave woman, but of the free woman.”

That sentence is not poetic. It is confrontational. Paul is telling believers that how they live reveals who they believe they are. Identity always precedes behavior. You do not act like a slave because rules exist. You act like a slave because you believe you are one. And you do not live freely because freedom is easy. You live freely because you trust the Father who gave it to you.

Galatians 4 is not a chapter you skim. It is a chapter that interrogates your faith.

Do you pray like a child or negotiate like an employee?

Do you obey because you are loved, or because you are afraid of being rejected?

Do you pursue holiness as response, or as currency?

Do you trust God’s timing, or do you quietly resent Him for not moving fast enough?

Paul is not trying to destroy faith. He is trying to rescue it from immaturity. He is calling believers out of spiritual adolescence and into adulthood. Adulthood in Christ does not mean fewer disciplines. It means deeper trust. It does not mean abandoning obedience. It means obedience flowing from love instead of anxiety.

There is a moment when faith must graduate from being managed to being inhabited.

Children need rules because they cannot yet discern wisdom. Adults carry wisdom internally. They do not need constant supervision because they have internalized values. Paul is saying that the Spirit inside you is not there to micromanage you. He is there to form Christ within you. And that formation cannot happen while fear remains in charge.

Many believers live exhausted lives not because God demands too much, but because they are still trying to earn what has already been given. They confuse discipline with distance. They confuse correction with condemnation. They confuse silence with abandonment. And so they cling to rituals because rituals feel measurable.

But inheritance is not measured. It is received.

Galatians 4 reminds us that God is not raising dependents. He is raising sons and daughters. He is not interested in producing rule-followers who never know His heart. He is forming people who carry His character into the world.

That is why Paul’s words still sting. Because they strip away the comfort of performance and leave us face to face with trust. And trust is always riskier than rules.

Yet this is the risk at the center of the gospel.

God trusted us enough to place His Spirit within us.

God trusted us enough to call us heirs.

God trusted us enough to move us out from under guardians and into relationship.

And He is still asking the same question today that Paul asked then.

Why are you going back to chains when you were born for inheritance?

Why are you living like a servant when you are called a child?

Why are you managing behavior when Christ wants to form your heart?

Galatians 4 does not end with comfort. It ends with identity. It leaves you standing at a crossroads, choosing between slavery that feels safe and freedom that requires trust.

And it quietly reminds you that growing up in faith is not about doing more for God.

It is about finally believing He meant what He said when He called you His child.

Your friend,
Douglas Vandergraph

Watch Douglas Vandergraph’s inspiring faith-based videos on YouTube.

Support the ministry by buying Douglas a coffee.

#Faith #ChristianLiving #Galatians #SpiritualGrowth #Grace #FreedomInChrist #BibleStudy #ChristianFaith #Hope #Transformation