Freedom That Fights Back: Galatians 5 and the Cost of Staying Free
Freedom is one of the most overused words in the modern Christian vocabulary, and at the same time one of the least examined. We speak of it casually, sing about it passionately, defend it politically, and claim it spiritually, yet many believers live as though freedom were a fragile idea they must constantly earn, protect, or justify. Galatians 5 does not treat freedom as a slogan. It treats it as a battlefield. Paul does not write this chapter as a poet admiring liberty from a distance. He writes as a man who has watched freedom be slowly traded away for comfort, control, and certainty, and who knows exactly how easily people drift back into chains they once celebrated escaping.
Galatians 5 opens with a statement that sounds simple but is anything but: “It is for freedom that Christ has set us free.” Paul does not say Christ set us free so that we could become better rule-followers, more respectable religious citizens, or safer versions of ourselves. He says freedom itself was the purpose. That single line reframes the entire Christian life. Freedom is not the reward at the end of obedience. Freedom is the starting line. Everything else flows from that reality, or it collapses into something else entirely.
Paul is writing to people who already believe in Jesus. That matters. This chapter is not aimed at skeptics or outsiders. It is aimed at churchgoing, Scripture-reading, Jesus-confessing believers who are slowly being convinced that freedom needs to be supplemented. That grace alone is not quite enough. That faith needs reinforcement. That the work of Christ, while impressive, might still require human completion. The danger Paul sees is not open rebellion but quiet regression. Not a rejection of Christ, but an addition to Him.
What makes Galatians 5 so unsettling is that Paul does not frame this as a minor theological disagreement. He frames it as a direct threat to the gospel itself. He warns that if they accept circumcision as a requirement for righteousness, Christ will be of no benefit to them. That statement shocks modern readers because it sounds extreme. How could one religious practice nullify the work of Christ? But Paul understands something we often miss: the moment you add a requirement to grace, grace ceases to function as grace. It becomes a contract. And contracts always have conditions, loopholes, and penalties.
The human heart loves contracts because contracts feel controllable. They give us leverage. They tell us where we stand. They allow comparison. Grace, on the other hand, leaves us exposed. Grace removes our bargaining chips. Grace strips away our ability to say, “I belong here because I did this.” That is why religious systems are so attractive. They give us something to point to. Something measurable. Something provable. Freedom, by contrast, requires trust. And trust feels dangerous when you are used to measuring your worth by performance.
Paul’s frustration in this chapter is not abstract. It is personal. He has watched people who were once alive with joy now live under the weight of spiritual anxiety. He has watched freedom turn into fear disguised as discipline. He has seen believers exchange the Spirit for supervision. That is why his tone sharpens. That is why he says he wishes those troubling them would go all the way with their self-mutilation. It is not cruelty. It is desperation. Paul knows what is at stake. He knows that once people are convinced they must earn what was freely given, they will never stop trying. And they will never rest.
One of the most misunderstood lines in Galatians 5 is Paul’s warning that freedom is not an opportunity for the flesh. Many readers take this as a limitation on freedom, as though Paul were saying, “Yes, you’re free, but not too free.” That interpretation misses his point entirely. Paul is not afraid of freedom producing chaos. He is warning that freedom can be misused when it is misunderstood. The flesh, in Paul’s writing, is not simply bad behavior. It is self-centered living. It is life curved inward, focused on self-preservation, self-gratification, and self-justification. When freedom is treated as permission rather than transformation, it becomes a tool for the very thing Christ came to free us from.
True freedom, in Paul’s vision, does not lead inward. It leads outward. “Serve one another humbly in love,” he says. That sentence alone dismantles the lie that freedom and responsibility are opposites. In the kingdom of God, freedom creates the capacity to love, not the excuse to avoid it. Slavery says, “I must.” Freedom says, “I can.” And what we do with that “can” reveals what kind of freedom we have embraced.
Paul then delivers one of the most penetrating insights in all of Scripture: the entire law is fulfilled in a single command, to love your neighbor as yourself. This is not a reduction of holiness. It is its fulfillment. The law was never meant to create rule experts. It was meant to shape people who reflect the character of God. Love is not the replacement for righteousness; it is the expression of it. Where love is absent, law multiplies. Where love is present, law finds its purpose.
The tragedy Paul highlights is that when believers turn on one another, biting and devouring each other, it is often in the name of righteousness. Legalism does not usually announce itself as cruelty. It presents itself as concern. As discernment. As protection of truth. Yet its fruit is division, suspicion, and exhaustion. Paul warns that communities consumed by this kind of conflict will eventually destroy themselves. Not because truth is fragile, but because lovelessness is corrosive.
This is where Paul introduces one of the most famous contrasts in the New Testament: life according to the flesh versus life according to the Spirit. These are not two categories of people, but two ways of living. Every believer navigates this tension daily. The flesh pulls toward control, impulse, and self-centeredness. The Spirit pulls toward trust, transformation, and love. What matters is not which impulses exist, but which ones are fed.
Paul’s list of the works of the flesh is often read as a checklist of forbidden behaviors, but it functions more like a diagnostic chart. Sexual immorality, idolatry, hatred, jealousy, fits of rage, selfish ambition, dissensions, factions, envy—these are not random sins. They are symptoms of a life trying to secure identity, satisfaction, and power apart from God. They are what emerge when freedom is replaced with fear and faith is replaced with performance.
When Paul says those who live like this will not inherit the kingdom of God, he is not issuing a threat to anxious believers who stumble. He is naming a reality. A life oriented around the flesh is incompatible with the kingdom because the kingdom operates on an entirely different power source. You cannot live by self-centered striving and expect to experience a reality built on self-giving love.
Then Paul shifts the entire tone of the chapter with a simple phrase: “But the fruit of the Spirit…” Notice what he does not say. He does not say “the works of the Spirit.” Fruit grows. It develops organically. It is not manufactured through effort but cultivated through connection. This alone exposes how deeply flawed performance-based spirituality is. You cannot will yourself into love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, or self-control. You can only remain connected to the source from which these qualities grow.
Each aspect of the fruit of the Spirit deserves slow reflection, not because they are lofty ideals, but because they are profoundly practical. Love is not sentimentality; it is self-giving commitment. Joy is not circumstantial happiness; it is grounded assurance. Peace is not the absence of conflict; it is internal stability. Patience is not passivity; it is endurance. Kindness and goodness are not weakness; they are strength directed outward. Faithfulness is not rigidity; it is reliability. Gentleness is not softness; it is power under control. Self-control is not suppression; it is alignment.
What is striking is that Paul presents these qualities not as goals to chase but as evidence of life in the Spirit. They are signs that freedom is functioning properly. They reveal a person no longer driven by fear of punishment or hunger for approval, but guided by trust in God’s work within them.
Paul concludes this section by stating that those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires. This is not a call to self-hatred or denial of humanity. It is a declaration of allegiance. To crucify the flesh is to refuse to let self-centered desire define reality. It is to say that identity no longer flows from impulse, achievement, or comparison, but from belonging to Christ.
The closing exhortation of Galatians 5 is deceptively simple: “Since we live by the Spirit, let us keep in step with the Spirit.” This is not about perfection. It is about direction. Keeping in step implies movement, attentiveness, and humility. It acknowledges missteps without surrendering progress. It invites believers into a daily posture of listening rather than striving.
What Galatians 5 ultimately confronts is not behavior but trust. Do we trust that Christ’s work is enough? Do we trust the Spirit to produce what law never could? Do we trust freedom more than control? The answers to these questions shape not only personal faith but communal life. Churches that trust freedom produce mature believers. Churches that fear it produce compliance and burnout.
Paul’s vision in this chapter is not reckless liberty. It is resilient freedom. Freedom that can withstand temptation because it is rooted in love. Freedom that does not collapse under pressure because it is sustained by the Spirit. Freedom that refuses to trade authenticity for approval or grace for guarantees.
Galatians 5 does not ask whether you believe in freedom. It asks whether you are willing to stay free. And staying free, Paul knows, will cost you something. It will cost you the illusion of control. It will cost you the comfort of comparison. It will cost you the security of measurable righteousness. But what it gives in return is life that actually looks like Christ.
In the next movement of this reflection, we will look more closely at what it means to “walk by the Spirit” in real, modern life, how subtle forms of legalism still creep into faith communities today, and how Galatians 5 offers not just a theology of freedom, but a way to recognize when freedom is quietly being lost again.
Galatians 5 does not merely diagnose the danger of losing freedom; it exposes how quietly that loss happens. Freedom is rarely stolen in dramatic moments. It is surrendered incrementally, often in the name of wisdom, order, or spiritual maturity. Paul understands that believers do not wake up one day and decide to abandon grace. They drift. They adapt. They respond to pressure. And over time, what once felt like joyful surrender to Christ becomes careful self-management disguised as faithfulness.
To walk by the Spirit, as Paul describes it, is not a mystical experience reserved for especially spiritual people. It is a posture of dependence that reshapes everyday decisions. Walking implies pace. It implies attentiveness. It implies responsiveness. You cannot walk by the Spirit while sprinting ahead in self-reliance or standing still in fear. Walking requires humility, because it means you are not leading. Someone else is setting the direction.
This is where modern Christianity often struggles. Many believers are taught how to behave but not how to discern. They learn rules without learning relationship. They master language without cultivating awareness. As a result, they substitute structure for sensitivity. Paul’s call to walk by the Spirit challenges that entire framework. It assumes that God is present, active, and communicative, not distant or silent. It assumes that transformation is relational before it is behavioral.
Legalism thrives where discernment is absent. When people do not know how to listen for the Spirit, they cling to formulas. When they are unsure how God leads, they prefer instructions. Rules feel safer than reliance because rules do not require intimacy. They can be followed at a distance. The Spirit, by contrast, invites closeness. He invites trust. And trust always feels riskier than regulation.
Paul’s insistence that circumcision obligates a person to obey the entire law reveals something crucial: partial legalism is impossible. The moment you adopt one requirement as necessary for righteousness, you are no longer operating under grace. You are under obligation. And obligation has no finish line. There is always another standard, another expectation, another comparison waiting. That is why legalistic environments are never peaceful. They cannot be. The system itself produces anxiety.
One of the most subtle ways freedom is lost today is through spiritual comparison. When believers measure their faith by how they stack up against others, they have already stepped away from the Spirit and into the flesh. Comparison feels spiritual because it often masquerades as accountability. But accountability rooted in fear does not produce growth; it produces concealment. People hide what they fear will disqualify them. The Spirit, however, draws things into the light because His goal is healing, not ranking.
Galatians 5 exposes how easily community can be destroyed when freedom is replaced by scrutiny. Paul’s warning about biting and devouring one another is painfully relevant. When believers lose confidence in grace, they begin policing each other. When assurance fades, judgment rises. Communities become tense not because sin is rampant, but because trust is absent. The irony is that in trying to protect holiness, they undermine the very environment where holiness can grow.
Walking by the Spirit also redefines self-control. In performance-based spirituality, self-control means suppression. It means white-knuckling obedience. In Spirit-led life, self-control is alignment. It is the result of desires being reordered, not merely restrained. The Spirit does not just tell you what not to do; He reshapes what you want. That kind of change cannot be produced by rules. It requires surrender.
This is why Paul’s language of crucifying the flesh is so important. Crucifixion is not behavior modification. It is a decisive break with an old source of identity. The flesh represents the belief that life can be secured through self-effort. To crucify it is to say, “This no longer defines me.” It is not about denying desire; it is about denying desire the authority to rule.
Living by the Spirit also reframes failure. In a legalistic system, failure threatens belonging. In a Spirit-led life, failure becomes information. It reveals where trust needs to deepen. It exposes where old patterns still exert influence. It invites return, not retreat. This is why Paul does not load Galatians 5 with warnings about losing salvation over missteps. His concern is direction, not perfection. He is far more worried about believers changing power sources than making mistakes.
Paul’s call to keep in step with the Spirit assumes ongoing movement. It acknowledges seasons. Some days the step is confident. Other days it is hesitant. What matters is attentiveness. Are you watching where the Spirit is leading, or are you defaulting to what feels safe? Are you responding to conviction, or merely managing appearances? These questions do not condemn; they clarify.
One of the great misunderstandings about freedom is the belief that it eliminates struggle. Paul says the opposite. He openly acknowledges conflict between the flesh and the Spirit. Freedom does not remove tension; it gives you a new way to navigate it. Instead of being driven by impulse or crushed by guilt, you are guided by relationship. The struggle itself becomes evidence that the Spirit is at work, not proof of failure.
Galatians 5 ultimately invites believers into maturity. Not maturity defined by rule mastery, but by relational depth. A mature believer is not one who never struggles, but one who knows where to turn when they do. A mature believer does not outsource discernment to systems alone; they cultivate sensitivity to the Spirit. A mature believer does not fear freedom; they steward it.
Paul’s frustration throughout this chapter is fueled by love. He knows what freedom costs because he has lived on both sides of it. He knows the exhaustion of striving and the rest of surrender. He knows the difference between obeying out of fear and serving out of love. And he refuses to let believers trade one for the other without warning them of the consequences.
Galatians 5 stands as a guardrail for every generation of the church. Whenever faith becomes heavy, joy disappears, and love thins out, this chapter asks a piercing question: have you stepped out of freedom without realizing it? Not by rejecting Christ, but by supplementing Him. Not by abandoning grace, but by distrusting it.
Freedom that comes from Christ does not make life easier in every sense, but it makes it honest. It strips away pretense. It exposes motives. It removes the need to prove oneself. And in doing so, it creates space for genuine transformation. The Spirit does not rush this process. He walks it.
Galatians 5 does not offer a shortcut to holiness. It offers a foundation. Stand firm, Paul says. Not because freedom is fragile, but because humans are forgetful. We forget how we were freed. We forget what we were saved from. We forget that the Christian life began not with effort, but with trust.
Staying free requires remembrance. It requires returning again and again to the truth that Christ is enough, the Spirit is active, and love fulfills what law never could. That kind of freedom does not shout. It bears fruit. And its fruit looks like a life slowly, steadily becoming more like Christ.
Your friend,
Douglas Vandergraph
Watch Douglas Vandergraph’s inspiring faith-based videos on YouTube
